CO129-324 - Governor Nathan - 1904 [10-12] — Page 142

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

COFY.

Enclosure 2.

39663!

2010 | 141

Hon. Colonial Secretary,

The view expressed by His Excellency in paragraphs 4 and 5 of the draft is I think correct.

In the case of so-called "Military Reserves" of the class indicated by the letter from the General Officer Commanding to the Acting Colonial Secretary dated 12th July, 1897, enclosing Colonel Storer's proposal as to Sywan Hill, to which proposal the Colonial Government consented in the Acting Colonial Secretary's reply dated 28th July, 1897, I am of opinion —

(1) that the War Department has only a right to call for the reserved areas when they are required for Military purposes, paying the Colony their market value;

(2) that when, and so far as, the reserved areas are not required for Military purposes, the War Department's right is ipso facto determined; and

(3) that the Colony, in consenting to reserve an area, does not assign to the War Department the ownership of the land, or the building rights upon it, but merely agrees that (as the matter is expressed in the letter from the Colonial Office to the War Office dated 23rd July, 1904,) no part of the reserved area shall be disposed of till it has been decided how much of it is required for Military purposes, and that meanwhile the Colony's active rights of ownership such as building rights shall (as His Excellency expresses it in paragraph 5 of the draft) be held in abeyance.

(Sd.). H. Sharp.

12th October, 1904.

Edit History

2026-06-01 21:02:25 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
COFY. Enclosure 2. 39663! 2010 | 141 Hon. Colonial Secretary, The view expressed by His Excellency in paragraphs 4 and 5 of the draft is I think correct. In the case of so-called "Military Reserves" of the class indicated by the letter from the General Officer Commanding to the Acting Colonial Secretary dated 12th July, 1897, enclosing Colonel Storer's proposal as to Sywan Hill, to which proposal the Colonial Government consented in the Acting Colonial Secretary's reply dated 28th July, 1897, I am of opinion (1) that the War Department has only a right to call for the reserved areas when they are required for Military purposes, paying the Colony their market value; (2) that when, and so far as, the reserved areas are not required for Military purposes, the War Department's right is ipso facto determined; and (3) that the Colony, in consenting to reserve an area, does not assign to the War Department the ownership of the land, or the building rights upon it, but merely agrees that (as the matter is expressed in the letter from the Colonial Office to the War Office dated 23rd July, 1904,) no part of the reserved area shall be disposed of till it has been decided how much of it is required for Military purposes, and that meanwhile the Colony's active rights of ownership such as building rights shall (as His Excellency expresses it in paragraph 5 of the draft) be held in abeyance. (Sd.). H. Sharp. 12th October, 1904.
Baseline (Original)
: کی کے وار ان سے COFY. Enclosure 2. 0.0. 39663! 2010 | 141 Hon. Colonial Secretary, The view expressed by His Excellency in paragraphs 4 and 5 of the draft is I think correct. In the case of so-called "Military Reserves" of the class indicated by the letter from the General Officer Commanding to the Acting Colonial Secretary dated 12th. July, 1997, enclosing Colonel Storer's proposal as to Sywan Hill, to which proposal the Colonial Government consented in the Acting Colonial Secretary's reply dated 28th. July, 1987, I am of opinion - (1) that the War Department Las only a right to call for the reserved areas when they are required for Military pur- poses, paying the Colony their market value: (2) that when, and so far as, the reserved areas are not required for Military purposes, the War Department's right is ipso facto determined: and (3) that the Colony, in consenting to reserve an area, does not assign to the har Department the ownership of the land, or the building rights upon it, but merely agrees that (as the matter is expressed in the letter from the Colonial Office to the War Office dated 23rd. July, 1904,) no part of the reserved area shall be disposed of till it has been decided how much of it is required for Military purposes, and that meanwhile the Colony's active rights of ownership such as building rights shall (as His Excellency expresses it in paragraph 5 of the draft) be held in abeyance. (Sd.). H. Sharp. 12th. October, 1904. į
2026-06-01 21:02:25 · Baseline
View content

:

کی کے وار ان سے

COFY.

Enclosure 2.

0.0.

39663!

2010 | 141

Hon. Colonial Secretary,

The view expressed by His Excellency in

paragraphs 4 and 5 of the draft is I think correct.

In the case of so-called "Military Reserves"

of the class indicated by the letter from the General Officer

Commanding to the Acting Colonial Secretary dated 12th. July,

1997, enclosing Colonel Storer's proposal as to Sywan Hill, to

which proposal the Colonial Government consented in the Acting

Colonial Secretary's reply dated 28th. July, 1987, I am of

opinion -

(1) that the War Department Las only a right to call

for the reserved areas when they are required for Military pur-

poses, paying the Colony their market value:

(2) that when, and so far as, the reserved areas

are not required for Military purposes, the War Department's

right is ipso facto determined: and

(3) that the Colony, in consenting to reserve an

area, does not assign to the har Department the ownership of the

land, or the building rights upon it, but merely agrees that (as

the matter is expressed in the letter from the Colonial Office to

the War Office dated 23rd. July, 1904,) no part of the reserved

area shall be disposed of till it has been decided how much of it

is required for Military purposes, and that meanwhile the Colony's

active rights of ownership such as building rights shall (as His Excellency expresses it in paragraph 5 of the draft) be held in

abeyance.

(Sd.). H. Sharp.

12th. October, 1904.

į

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.